This blog is an outlet for my personal thoughts and views. It is generally concerned with life, science, nature and the world around us. It will often cover items about surfing, or should that be especially about surfing. There may also be some philosophical discourse. There will not be any politics and very little religion. I must point out all views expressed are my own and are not intended to offend anyone, or be taken as proven facts - there are times when I have been proven to be incorrect or misguided. While I try to be accurate, I am human and will make mistakes, so please be understanding.

Gallery

Sunday, 5 September 2010

Well that's probable

Following on from the previous interesting question about the probability of the second child being a boy and the importance of specifying a day, here is the solution.


 First if you start from the assumption that you know I have two children and what is the probability that I have two boys.
I can therefore have - B/B, B/G, G/B, G/G
Since the question is about the probability of two boys the G/G option can be eliminated. That leaves three scenarios of which one is B/B, so the probability of two boys is 1/3
Now looking at the original scenario using the same technique. Lets call a boy born on Tuesday BTu. and list all the scenarios.
1)BTu + Girl on any day of the week = seven possibilities
2)Girl born on any day of the week + BTu = seven possibilities
3)BTu + boy born on any day of the week = seven possibilities
4)Boy born on any day of the week + BTu = six possibilities (the situation where both boys were born on a Tuesday was counted in scenario 3 and must be discounted as we are looking for equally likely possibilities).
Adding all probabilities gives 27 in total ((7 x 3) + 6), which represents all equally likely combinations of children with specified gender and birth day. Of these combinations 13 are two boys . Therefore the probability is 13/27.
Consider that 13/27 is very different from 1/3 where the key point about day of the week is not considered. This seems quite remarkable and apparently the rarer the trait specified the closer the probability approaches to 1/2
Quite interesting, especially if your a mathematician.